What Are Brogue Shoes?

Our answer from the shop in Geneva: where brogues came from, how to tell full, semi and quarter brogues apart, and how a brogue relates to the Oxford and the Derby.

Crockett & Jones Pembroke Tan, a full brogue Derby in Scotch grain leather

A brogue is any shoe or boot decorated with rows of small punched holes along the seams of the upper. That punching is called broguing, and it is a decoration rather than a style of shoe. An Oxford, a Derby, a monk strap, a loafer and even a Chelsea boot can all be brogued. As a rule, the more holes a shoe carries, the less formal it is.

Here is where the holes came from, how to tell the four main types apart, and how a brogue relates to the Oxford and the Derby. It is a subject close to our hearts, given the name above our door.

Where Brogues Come From

The word comes from the Irish bróg and the Scottish Gaelic bròg, both meaning simply “shoe”. Both go back to the Old Norse brók, a leg covering, one of the words Viking settlers left behind in Ireland.

The first brogues were rough shoes of untanned hide, worn by people working the wet, boggy countryside of Ireland and the Scottish Highlands. The story most often told is that the holes were cut to let water drain out and to help the leather dry overnight. In 1543, a Scot named John Elder wrote to Henry VIII describing shoes of raw leather with holes cut into them, one of the earliest written records of the idea.

For a long time brogues remained country shoes, worn for walking, shooting and golf, and thought too rustic for town. That changed in the 1930s, when Edward, Prince of Wales, wore them on the golf course and well beyond it, and helped carry them into the city.

The word took a second path too. By the early 1700s, English speakers were using “brogue” for an Irish accent, most likely borrowed from the shoe.

Today the holes are almost always decorative. On a modern brogue the punching goes through the outer leather only, with a lining underneath, so your feet stay dry.

Crockett & Jones Pembroke in black Scotch grain, a full brogue Derby

The Crockett & Jones Pembroke in black Scotch grain. The punching goes through the outer leather only, with a full lining underneath.

Full, Semi, Quarter and Longwing Brogues

The type of brogue is set by the shape of the toe cap and how much punching it carries.

Full brogue. The toe cap comes to a point and sweeps back along both sides of the shoe in the shape of a W, like a pair of wings. That is why Americans call it a wingtip. A full brogue has a decorative pattern of holes on the toe, called a medallion, and punching along every seam. It is the most decorative and the most relaxed of the four. The Crockett & Jones Pembroke, a full brogue Derby, is a good example.

Semi brogue. Also called a half brogue. The toe cap runs straight across the shoe with a punched edge, and there is a medallion in the centre of the toe. It keeps some of the character of a full brogue in a cleaner line, which makes it one of the most versatile shoes in a wardrobe.

Quarter brogue. The same straight, punched toe cap, but no medallion. It is the plainest and most formal brogue, and sits comfortably with a dark suit.

Longwing brogue. The wings do not stop halfway down the sides but run the full length of the shoe and meet at the heel. Longwings were especially popular in the United States, where they are sometimes called American brogues.

Two less common variants are worth knowing. An austerity brogue has the wingtip shape with no holes at all, and a blind brogue does the opposite, with the wingtip pattern punched into a plain toe. The ghillie brogue, from Scotland, has no tongue and long laces wrapped around the ankle, and is still worn with Highland dress.

Bontoni Vittorio II Wingtip, a full brogue Oxford in calf leather

The Bontoni Vittorio II, a full brogue with its wingtip and medallion, hand welted in Italy.

Brogue, Oxford or Derby?

A common question is whether a shoe is a brogue or an Oxford. In fact the two words answer different questions. Oxford and Derby describe how the shoe laces. Brogue describes how it is decorated. So a shoe can be both.

On an Oxford, the two pieces that hold the eyelets are stitched underneath the front of the shoe, so they close into a neat V. This is called closed lacing, and it gives the sleekest, most formal line. In French, and so in much of Geneva, an Oxford is a richelieu. On a Derby, those pieces are stitched on top and open freely. This open lacing gives more room across the top of the foot, which suits anyone with a high instep, and reads a little more relaxed.

Put the two ideas together and you have a simple scale. The most formal brogue is a quarter brogue Oxford in black or dark brown calf, which works with a suit for business. Next comes the semi brogue Oxford, smart enough for the office. A full brogue Derby, especially in Scotch grain or suede, belongs with tweed, flannel, chinos and denim. On a rubber sole it also makes sense in a Geneva winter, as we explained in our article on Chelsea boots.

Crockett & Jones Fairford, a full brogue Oxford with closed lacing
Crockett & Jones Pembroke Tan, a full brogue Derby with open lacing

The same decoration, two ways of lacing. Left, the Crockett & Jones Fairford, a full brogue Oxford. Right, the Pembroke, a full brogue Derby.

One practical point: the holes collect polish and dust. Before polishing, brush the punching with a soft brush, and use cream rather than heavy wax on the perforated areas, so the holes do not fill up with residue.

Most of the brogues on our shelves are Goodyear welted or hand welted, so our master cobbler can resole them when the time comes. If you are not sure whether an Oxford or a Derby suits your foot better, come and try both in the shop in Geneva.

Artikel kaufen

Fragen, die uns häufig gestellt werden

Why do brogues have holes?
They began as drainage holes in rough shoes worn in the boggy countryside of Ireland and Scotland, letting water out and the leather dry. On modern brogues the holes are decorative and the shoe is lined.
What is the difference between a brogue and an Oxford?
An Oxford is defined by its closed lacing; a brogue by its punched decoration. They are not opposites, and a full brogue Oxford is one of the most classic shoes there is.
Are brogues formal?
Less formal than a plain shoe. A quarter or semi brogue Oxford in black or dark brown works with a business suit. Full brogues are best kept for smart casual dress, and none are right for black tie.
Can you wear brogues with jeans?
Yes. A full brogue Derby in Scotch grain or suede is one of the best smart shoes to wear with denim.